November 19, 2026
In June, a 2005 house on East Amy Lane in The Villages in St. Johns Woods went under contract 27 days after listing. It closed on June 18 at $825,000, which was $26,000 over its $799,000 asking price. The house has 2,040 square feet on a 0.22-acre lot. A week later, a 2019 house on St. Johns Woods Parkway with 2,096 square feet closed at $731,500 after starting at $739,000. In September, another 2019 house of the same size on the same parkway, also on a 0.22-acre lot, sold for $720,000.
The house that was 14 years older and slightly smaller brought roughly $95,000 to $105,000 more. That gap repeats across this year's sales in the neighborhood. It means a buyer comparing The Villages with newer communities on Johns Island is comparing two different products that happen to share a pool, a clubhouse and an entrance on Maybank Highway.
The Villages in St. Johns Woods has about 188 single-family homes off Maybank Highway. They were built in phases. The original Villages sections, Parkside and Woodside, came first, starting in 2003. The Arbors, built by Pulte, and Lakeside, built by Crescent Homes, were added later, mostly between 2015 and 2021.
Here are the 2026 closings, January through mid-November, sorted by year built. Price per square foot is sale price divided by heated square footage.
| Address | Built | Closed | Sale price | Sq ft | $/sq ft |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5142 Coral Reef Dr | 2004 | May 1 | $725,000 | 1,942 | $373 |
| 4053 E Amy Ln | 2005 | June 18 | $825,000 | 2,040 | $404 |
| 5103 Coral Reef Dr | 2005 | Aug. 17 | $849,000 | 2,157 | $394 |
| 4091 E Amy Ln | 2006 | April 20 | $625,000 | 1,687 | $370 |
| 5144 Coral Reef Dr | 2007 | Aug. 7 | $898,000 | 2,696 | $333 |
| 3429 Acorn Drop Ln | 2015 | June 22 | $725,000 | 2,275 | $319 |
| 2128 St Johns Woods Pkwy | 2019 | June 26 | $731,500 | 2,096 | $349 |
| 2134 St Johns Woods Pkwy | 2019 | Sept. 24 | $720,000 | 2,096 | $343 |
| 2186 St Johns Woods Pkwy | 2019 | May 8 | $730,000 | 2,128 | $343 |
| 2008 Bouganvillia Dr | 2019 | Aug. 4 | $699,990 | 2,816 | $249 |
| 2026 Geranium Ln | 2020 | Aug. 17 | $789,000 | 2,816 | $280 |
| 2018 Pearl Stone St | 2021 | March 31 | $789,900 | 2,828 | $279 |
| 2024 Pearl Stone St | 2021 | June 26 | $642,000 | 2,320 | $277 |
| 1806 Swing Ln | 2021 | May 28 | $775,000 | 2,830 | $274 |
The five 2004–2007 homes sold for $333 to $404 per square foot, and their median was about $373. The 2015–2021 homes sold for $249 to $349, with a median near $280. The fastest and fullest-price results this year were on Coral Reef Drive and East Amy Lane. Three of the older homes closed at their original asking price, one closed above it, and the weakest older result still came in at about 97% of its first ask. The slowest result in the newer group was 2008 Bouganvillia Drive in The Arbors. It needed close to five months and a cut from $734,900 before it closed.
Size could account for part of this, because the older homes run smaller. The pairing in the opening is the clearest test because it holds size and lot nearly constant. A 2,040-square-foot 2005 house sold for about $404 a foot, and 2,096-square-foot 2019 houses sold for about $343 to $349. Most of the gap remains even when the houses are matched.
The 2015–2021 homes in The Villages compete with homes outside the neighborhood, and the comparison shows it. In Sea Island Preserve, eight closings between June and early November 2026 sold for roughly $239 to $340 per square foot. That range almost exactly matches the $249 to $349 range for the newer Villages homes. The closest pair is 3202 Hugh Bennett Drive, a 2024 Sea Island Preserve home with 2,430 square feet on 0.36 acres. It closed on Nov. 3 at $825,000, about $340 a foot. That is close to what the 2019 Arbors houses on St. Johns Woods Parkway brought on 0.22-acre lots.
Oakfield sits below both. Six Oakfield closings from August through early November 2026 ran from about $204 to $277 per square foot, and 2355 Brinkley Road, a 2021 home with 3,550 square feet, closed at $800,000 on Nov. 4. We covered the Oakfield side of this market in our read on Johns Island's September median. Here, the useful point is that a buyer with about $780,000 can choose a 2021 Villages house of roughly 2,800 square feet or an Oakfield house several hundred feet larger.
A buyer looking at an Arbors or Lakeside house is shopping in the same market as these communities. The per-foot numbers line up because those buyers are cross-shopping the same kind of house: recent construction, open plan, builder floor plans with names like the Ravenwood plan at 1806 Swing Lane. Those houses have close substitutes across Johns Island, and their prices reflect it.
The original-section homes are not on larger land. The 2005 East Amy Lane house that sold above asking sits on 0.22 acres, the same as the 2019 parkway house. 4091 East Amy Lane sits on 0.14 acres. Every Sea Island Preserve sale listed above had a larger lot, and those lots ran from 0.34 to 0.93 acres.
The premium pays for the plan and its position. The original Villages has Lowcountry bungalows, craftsman cottages, Charleston singles and double-porch homes on a lantern-lined parkway with sidewalks. Parkside sits beside a 6-acre central park with trails, bridges and boardwalks through protected wetlands. St. John's Square is close enough for most homes to reach on foot or by bike. Its tenants include Snow Monkeys, The Natural, Gold Star Coffee, Anytime Fitness and Scramblers Golf Club. The listing for 5103 Coral Reef Drive describes a mature, tree-lined street, and the 4053 East Amy Lane listing describes Australian cypress hardwoods and a detached two-car garage.
Newer communities can copy the porch, but they cannot copy two decades of tree growth or a walkable distance to an existing shopping square. We walked that radius in our summer guide to the Maybank corridor around The Villages. Because nothing new on the island directly competes with these streets, an original-section listing can sell above its asking price at more than $400 a foot while the newer homes a few hundred yards away price like new construction.
The premium is a per-foot premium, and it has a ceiling. 4013 East Amy Lane is a 2005 house with 2,660 square feet, a pond view and a metal roof. It came to market on Aug. 26 at $990,000, about $372 a foot. Sept. 24 brought the first price reduction, with more on Oct. 6 and Oct. 30, and in mid-November it was listed at $899,000.
That brings it to about $338 a foot, which matches the original section's largest 2026 sale. 5144 Coral Reef Drive has 2,696 square feet and closed in August at its full $898,000 asking price, about $333 a foot. The largest older home to sell this year closed at $898,000, and the one still listed has come down to $899,000. Above that price, buyers have other choices on Johns Island. In October 2026, the island's detached-home median sale price was $790,000, sellers received 95.5% of their original list price, and homes took 58 days to sell, according to the Charleston Trident Association of REALTORS October report. The original Villages sections did better than that on sale-to-list in 2026. The per-foot premium holds most firmly on smaller homes, and the largest older homes sell closer to the island's general price levels.
Maybank Highway is the neighborhood's front door, and 2027 will be a construction year on it. The northern pitchfork connector between Maybank at Fenwick Hall Allee and River Road is open, and the Post and Courier reported that city and county leaders marked its completion on March 25. The next project adds a second outbound lane where Maybank now narrows to one near the River Road intersection. Live 5 reported in September that construction was expected to start early next year and finish in fall 2027. Charleston Mayor William Cogswell told the station the island's infrastructure work is coming "in the next 12 to 24 months." On Charleston County's Maybank Highway project page, the 100% plans are listed as accepted and the bid package as being with procurement.
A buyer who closes this winter will probably own through that construction year. For an original-section home, the value comes partly from being near Maybank. A buyer can count a smoother outbound drive in late 2027 as a reason to buy now, but should not price it in yet.
Pull comparables for a Villages home by section and build year before looking at the neighborhood average. An Arbors or Lakeside house should be compared with Sea Island Preserve and the newer Johns Island stock, and an original-section house should be compared with Coral Reef Drive and East Amy Lane. The St. John's Woods Property Owners Association bills assessments quarterly, so confirm the current amount with the association before you write an offer. Sellers can use the same division. Price a 2,000-square-foot original-section house per foot against the 2026 East Amy sales, and price a 2,700-square-foot one by total dollars against the roughly $900,000 level.
If you're deciding between an original-section house and an Arbors house in The Villages, or need a sale-by-sale read on what your own home in St. Johns Woods would bring this winter, Anthony Barrasso can go through the comparables with you street by street. Let's Connect, or start with a home valuation.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Experience the confidence that comes from working with a seasoned Broker committed to protecting your goals and delivering exceptional results. Contact Anthony today to start your home searching journey!